Friday, February 15, 2008

Where the Framers failed

When the Framers - whom I greatly admire - produced the U.S. Constitution as the framework for our government they made one very serious mistake - a mistake that is now revealing itself for perhaps the first time in our 200+ year history: They assumed those holding the reins of government would take the oath of office seriously:
The Senators and Representatives before mentioned, and the members of the several state legislatures, and all executive and judicial officers, both of the United States and of the several states, shall be bound by oath or affirmation, to support this Constitution...
[Article VI, U.S. Constitution]
... and they assumed that when an office-holder clearly violated this oath, that person would be removed from office.

In previous posts I've noted that Presidential "signing statements" have no Constitutional basis, yet W is not the first president to get away with 'em.
Article II
Before he enter on the execution of his office, he shall take the following oath or affirmation:--
"I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will faithfully execute the office of President of the United States, and will to the best of my ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States."
Recently we've heard from one of the Justices of our Supreme Court:
Scalia Says 'So-Called Torture' Cannot Be Ruled Out as Interrogation Method
U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia said that aggressive physical interrogation could be appropriate to learn where a bomb was hidden shortly before it was set to explode or to discover the plans or whereabouts of a terrorist group.

"As unlikely as that is, it would be absurd to say you couldn't, I don't know, stick something under the fingernail, smack him in the face. It would be absurd to say you couldn't do that," Scalia said in an interview with British Broadcasting Radio Corp.
"... stick something under the fingernail"???

No, there is no Article or Amendment that directly addresses the use of torture to compel the giving of information. Amendment V provides that one cannot be compelled to testify against oneself - but this does not directly address the use of torture to extract information other than a confession. Amendment V also provides that no one be deprived of "life, liberty, or property without due process of law", but again - this does not directly address the question of torture to obtain information deemed vital to national security.

Yes, Amendment VIII prohibits the infliction of "cruel and unusual punishments", but the word "punishments" suggests that this applies to sentences for criminal offences after a conviction is obtained, and need not apply to the use of torture as an interrogation technique. (Tho' this Amendment's prohibition of "excessive bail" could be used as the basis for an argument that "cruel and unusual punishments" are prohibited even before a conviction is obtained... One wishes the Framers had been more precise!)

The Framers - most (all?) of them of English heritage - almost certainly celebrated Guy Fawkes Day as children. They were not ignorant of the possibility of plots against the Government. The "ticking bomb" scenario would not be foreign to them (tho' they may have used a different metaphor... the "lit fuse" scenario, perhaps).

Why did they not include a prohibition of torture under these circumstances in the Bill of Rights? Two answers present themselves:
1. They intended to allow torture under the "lit fuse" scenario.
2. It never crossed their minds that men of goodwill would ever consider the use of torture! - why outlaw something that will never happen?
With no evidence to support my conclusion, other than both the Constitution's and the Federalist Papers's silence - I believe that alternative #2 is more likely.

That a sitting Justice on the United States Supreme Court would suggest that there are circumstances under which sticking "something under the fingernail" might be justified is ... incredible!!!

Stop the madness!

"Quaestiones sunt fallaces et inefficaces"

"Quaestiones sunt fallaces et inefficaces"
["Torture is deceptive and ineffectual."
Nicholas Eymerich, inquisitor general of the Inquisition of the Crown of Aragon; 1357-1360, 1366(?)-1381(?)]

Note: This guy was NOT a humanist! In fact, "[h]e was the first inquisitor to get around the Church's prohibition against torturing a subject twice by interpreting [the] directive very liberally, permitting a separate instance of torture for a separate charge of heresy."
[Wikipedia entry, Nicholas Eymerich]

Presumably after several years of trying to extract confessions under torture, he arrived at the now well-known conclusion:
"Torture is deceptive and ineffectual."
For what it's worth:

EVERY reputable source on the Spanish Inquisition that I've found on the web lists two forms of torture used by that august institution:
the garrucha or pulleys
and
the water-torture
... and "the water-torture" is consistently described in terms that sound identical to what we are pleased to call waterboarding.

Maybe members of W's Administration don't know it, maybe members of the Republican Party don't know it... BUT:
Waterboarding is torture!
Stop the madness!

I can't believe my country is having this debate!

Lieberman says some waterboarding OK
By PETER URBAN
Connecticut Post Online
14 Feb 2008
WASHINGTON — Connecticut Sen. Joe Lieberman reluctantly acknowledged Thursday that he does not believe waterboarding is torture, but believes the interrogation technique should be available only under the most extreme circumstances.
...
"You want to be able to use emergency tech to try to get the information out of that person," Lieberman said. Of course, Lieberman believes such authority has limits. He does not believe the president could authorize having hot coals pressed on someone's flesh to obtain that information.
The difference, he said, is that waterboarding is mostly psychological and there is no permanent physical damage. "It is not like putting burning coals on people's bodies. The person is in no real danger. The impact is psychological," Lieberman said.
Well, it's not hot coals! This guy was almost elected VP as a Democrat???

Just for grins, let's hear from someone who thought seriously about war:
“For centuries all wounded and such unwounded prisoners as were valueless as slaves had their throats cut. No one was shocked; it was the custom. Finally, it occurred to some altruistic and thoughtful soldier that while the practice was excellent so long as he was the victor, it had it's drawbacks in the not unlikely event of his being the vanquished. The notion of humane treatment for the foe was born. Years of use sanctified the idea; it became the custom. Yet, the horrid thought pops up that help for the helpless sprang from love of ourselves, not of others; from fear of retaliation.”
[THE EFFECT OF WEAPONS ON WAR, Major George S. Patton, Jr., Cavalry Journal, November 1930]
This, ultimately, is the reason not to torture: by making torture (euphemistically, “enhanced interrogation”) national policy, we expose our soldiers, our diplomats, and ourselves to the same treatment without recourse to any court, not even the court of public opinion. We put ourselves beyond the pale of law, of custom, of civilization. We invite retaliation.

And... aren't conservatives the ones who presumably abhor moral relativism? What happened to that principle? When "the ends justify the means" we have lost our bearings!

Here's another fun quotation:
She said "If I knew what to say I would say it. Oh Señor, I don't know what I have to say-- Oh! Oh! they are killing me--if they would tell me what--Oh, Señores! Oh, my heart!" Then she asked why they wished her to tell what she could not tell and cried repeatedly "O, miserable me" Then she said "Lord bear witness that they are killing me without my being able to confess." She was told that if she wished to tell the truth before the water was poured she should do so and discharge her conscience. She said that she could not speak and that she was a sinner. Then the linen toca was placed [in her throat] and she said "Take it away, I am strangling and am sick in the stomach." A jar of water was then poured down, after which she was told to tell the truth. She clamored for confession, saying that she was dying. She was told that the torture would be continued till she told the truth and was admonished to tell it, but though she was questioned repeatedly she remained silent. Then the inquisitor, seeing her exhausted by the torture, ordered it to be suspended.
['...a very moderate case of water-torture, carried only to a single jarra, administered in 1568 by the tribunal of Toledo to Elvira del Campo, accused of not eating pork and of putting on "clean linen on Saturdays. She admitted the acts but denied heretical intent and was tortured on intention." '
A History of the Inquisition of Spain, Volume 3, Henry Charles Lea, 1906/7]
Psychological trauma is no less damaging than physical trauma. Would that Lieberman et al. could understand that!

Stop the madness!

More numbers: W's economy, 2001-2006

GDP growth, 2001-2006: 2.74% per year
Upper 5% of households, income growth: 0.30% per year
Median household, income growth: 0.05% per year

So, yes, under W, the economy has grown since 2001 at a rate of 2.74% per annum.

But no one seems to be seeing that growth:
- the upper 5% of households saw their income increase by an anemic 0.30% per annum.
- median household income "grew" at stagnant 0.05% per annum

This may explain why no one seems to believe W's great economic numbers - the past 6 years just haven't looked that great!

For what it's worth: GDP has increased steadily from 2000-2006; that 2001 recession was short and shallow.
(From 2001 to 2002, all household percentiles saw decrease in income.)

[For the purists out there: yes, I probably ought use 2000 as the base year. It doesn't look any better:
- GDP: 2.4% per year growth
- Upper 5% of households: 0.46% per year
- Median households: decrease 0.39% per year]

Congressman Silvestre Reyes's Letter to the President, in full

Washington, DC - Congressman Silvestre Reyes, D-TX, Chairman of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, sent the following letter to President George W. Bush today regarding the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA). The text of the letter is below:

President George W. Bush

The White House

1600 Pennsylvania Ave., NW

Washington, DC 20500

Dear Mr. President:

The Preamble to our Constitution states that one of our highest duties as public officials is to "provide for the common defence." As an elected Member of Congress, a senior Member of the House Armed Services Committee, and Chairman of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, I work everyday to ensure that our defense and intelligence capabilities remain strong in the face of serious threats to our national security.

Because I care so deeply about protecting our country, I take strong offense to your suggestion in recent days that the country will be vulnerable to terrorist attack unless Congress immediately enacts legislation giving you broader powers to conduct warrantless surveillance of Americans' communications and provides legal immunity for telecommunications companies that participated in the Administration's warrantless surveillance program.

Today, the National Security Agency (NSA) has authority to conduct surveillance in at least three different ways, all of which provide strong capability to monitor the communications of possible terrorists.

First, NSA can use its authority under Executive Order 12333 to conduct surveillance abroad of any known or suspected terrorist. There is no requirement for a warrant. There is no requirement for probable cause. Most of NSA's collection occurs under this authority.

Second, NSA can use its authority under the Protect America Act, enacted last August, to conduct surveillance here in the U.S of any foreign target. This authority does not "expire" on Saturday, as you have stated. Under the PAA, orders authorizing surveillance may last for one year - until at least August 2008. These orders may cover every terrorist group without limitation. If a new member of the group is identified, or if a new phone number or email address is identified, the NSA may add it to the existing orders, and surveillance can begin immediately. We will not "go dark."

Third, in the remote possibility that a new terrorist organization emerges that we have never previously identified, the NSA could use existing authority under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) to monitor those communications. Since its establishment nearly 30 years ago, the FISA Court has approved nearly every application for a warrant from the Department of Justice. In an emergency, NSA or the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) may begin surveillance immediately, and a FISA Court order does not have to be obtained for three days. The former head of FISA operations for the Department of Justice has testified publicly that emergency authorization may be granted in a matter of minutes.

As you know, the 1978 FISA law, which has been modernized and updated numerous times since 9/11, was instrumental in disrupting the terrorist plot in Germany last summer. Those who say that FISA is outdated do not understand the strength of this important tool.

If our nation is left vulnerable in the coming months, it will not be because we don't have enough domestic spying powers. It will be because your Administration has not done enough to defeat terrorist organizations - including al Qaeda -- that have gained strength since 9/11. We do not have nearly enough linguists to translate the reams of information we currently collect. We do not have enough intelligence officers who can penetrate the hardest targets, such as al Qaeda. We have surged so many intelligence resources into Iraq that we have taken our eye off the ball in Afghanistan and Pakistan. As a result, you have allowed al Qaeda to reconstitute itself on your watch.

You have also suggested that Congress must grant retroactive immunity to telecommunications companies. As someone who has been briefed on our most sensitive intelligence programs, I can see no argument why the future security of our country depends on whether past actions of telecommunications companies are immunized.

The issue of telecom liability should be carefully considered based on a full review of the documents that your Administration withheld from Congress for eight months. However, it is an insult to the intelligence of the American people to say that we will be vulnerable unless we grant immunity for actions that happened years ago.

Congress has not been sitting on its hands. Last November, the House passed responsible legislation to authorize the NSA to conduct surveillance of foreign terrorists and to provide clarity and legal protection to our private sector partners who assist in that surveillance.

The proper course is now to conference the House bill with the Senate bill that was passed on Tuesday. There are significant differences between these two bills and a conference, in regular order, is the appropriate mechanism to resolve the differences between these two bills. I urge you, Mr. President, to put partisanship aside and allow Republicans in Congress to arrive at a compromise that will protect America and protect our Constitution.

I, for one, do not intend to back down - not to the terrorists and not to anyone, including a President, who wants Americans to cower in fear.

We are a strong nation. We cannot allow ourselves to be scared into suspending the Constitution. If we do that, we might as well call the terrorists and tell them that they have won.

Sincerely,

Silvestre Reyes

Member of Congress

Chairman, House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence

Thursday, February 14, 2008

Hmmm... here's a thought

What happens if every Executive Department simply ignores W's dictates during his final months in office?

Seems like we might be seeing the beginnings of this already...
Think Progress reports that Mukasey, in an NPR interview, declared,
OK, let’s assume that the president wants, despite a finding of illegality under law, to have waterboarding done, who is it precisely that he’s going to get to do it? He would virtually have to do it himself.
Followed today by...
FEMA plans trailer exodus over chemical
By MICHAEL KUNZELMAN, Associated Press Writer
14 Feb 2008
NEW ORLEANS - After downplaying the risks for months, the Federal Emergency Management Agency said Thursday it will rush to move Gulf Coast hurricane victims out of roughly 35,000 government-issued trailers because tests found dangerous levels of formaldehyde fumes.
Okay, it's not much... but it may be a first: one of W's agencies acting on the basis of science.

Last fall's Iran NIE suggested the intelligence community would no longer be led by the nose by W/Cheney and their neocon enablers.

Now... if EPA decided to grant California's emissions waiver, we'd be seeing something truly amazing! (Yeah, I know: I'm not holding my breath.)

Stop the madness!

Finding a voice, at last!

Atrios at Eschaton prints the full text of Rep. Silvetre Reyes's (D-TX) letter to W. Go read it: it's a doozy!

My favorite paragraph:
If our nation is left vulnerable in the coming months, it will not be because we don't have enough domestic spying powers. It will be because your Administration has not done enough to defeat terrorist organizations - including al Qaeda -- that have gained strength since 9/11. We do not have nearly enough linguists to translate the reams of information we currently collect. We do not have enough intelligence officers who can penetrate the hardest targets, such as al Qaeda. We have surged so many intelligence resources into Iraq that we have taken our eye off the ball in Afghanistan and Pakistan. As a result, you have allowed al Qaeda to reconstitute itself on your watch.
In the paragraphs preceding this, Rep. Reyes identifies three (3) existing mechanisms that provide NSA with "... strong capability to monitor the communications of possible terrorists."

The second paragraph establishes the tone:
Because I care so deeply about protecting our country, I take strong offense to your suggestion in recent days that the country will be vulnerable to terrorist attack unless Congress immediately enacts legislation giving you broader powers to conduct warrantless surveillance of Americans' communications and provides legal immunity for telecommunications companies that participated in the Administration's warrantless surveillance program.
I almost forgot: both opening & closing paragraphs reference U.S. Constitution:
The Preamble to our Constitution states that one of our highest duties as public officials is to "provide for the common defence." As an elected Member of Congress, a senior Member of the House Armed Services Committee, and Chairman of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence, I work everyday to ensure that our defense and intelligence capabilities remain strong in the face of serious threats to our national security.
...
We are a strong nation. We cannot allow ourselves to be scared into suspending the Constitution. If we do that, we might as well call the terrorists and tell them that they have won.
I'm going to send this guy's campaign committee $ today!

Please, read the entire letter!
[It might have been easier for me to copy/paste it here... but visiting Atrios at Eschaton is a good idea!]

... and please, Democratic candidates, take Rep. Reyes as a model: here's how to confront W! - with angry, deliberative, fact-laden argument.

Thank you, Rep. Silvestre Reyes!